Are menstrual cups better for you than tampons?

A Deep Dive into Materials, Safety, Cost & Sustainability

Periods are personal, and so is period care. While tampons have been around for decades, menstrual cups have gained major popularity as a reusable, eco-friendly alternative. But are they actually better for you than tampons?

Let’s break it down and compare menstrual cups vs. tampons across the areas that matter most: materials, usage, safety, cost, comfort, and the environment.

🧪 1. MATERIALS: What's Inside Matters

Tampons

  • Made of cotton, rayon, or a blend

  • Often bleached or treated with chemicals

  • Sometimes include fragrances (which can irritate sensitive skin)

  • Wrapped in plastic or synthetic materials

Menstrual Cups

  • Made of medical-grade silicone, TPE, or rubber

  • Hypoallergenic and non-toxic

  • No dyes, bleaches, or fragrances

  • Durable and safe for long-term use

✅ Winner: Menstrual Cups — safer materials, especially for those with sensitivities or allergies.

⏱️ 2. USAGE: How Long Do They Last?

Tampons

  • Wear time: 4–8 hours max

  • Must be replaced multiple times per day

  • Risk of Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS) if left in too long

  • Different absorbency levels needed for each flow type

Menstrual Cups

  • Wear time: up to 12 hours

  • One cup for all flow levels (just empty more often on heavy days)

  • No fibers left behind

  • Lower TSS risk when used correctly

✅ Winner: Menstrual Cups — fewer changes, longer wear time, and safer with proper care.

💸 3. COST: Upfront vs. Long-Term

Tampons

  • ~$6–10 per box

  • Used monthly = ~$120+ per year

  • Always buying more

Menstrual Cups

  • ~$25–40 one-time cost

  • Lasts 5–10 years

  • Total cost = just a few dollars per year

✅ Winner: Menstrual Cups — huge savings over time.

🌍 4. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: Reuse vs. Waste

Tampons

  • Single-use: creates thousands of waste products over a lifetime

  • Packaging, applicators, and wrappers = plastic pollution

  • Tampons often end up in oceans and landfills

Menstrual Cups

  • Reusable for up to 10 years

  • One product = hundreds of tampons avoided

  • Minimal packaging waste

  • Most cups are recyclable at end of life

✅ Winner: Menstrual Cups — far more sustainable and eco-conscious.

🚽 5. BEGINNER EXPERIENCE: Ease of Use

Tampons

  • Familiar for many

  • Easy to insert and dispose

  • Some discomfort if inserted incorrectly

  • Can cause dryness or irritation

Menstrual Cups

  • Steeper learning curve (folding, inserting, sealing)

  • Can be intimidating at first

  • Once mastered, many find it more comfortable and leak-free

  • No dryness or friction

🤔 Tie — Tampons are easier for beginners, but menstrual cups become more comfortable long-term.

🩺 6. BODY HEALTH & COMFORT

Tampons

  • Can dry out the vaginal wall

  • Sometimes leave fibers behind

  • Associated (rarely) with TSS

  • May contain pesticides from cotton

Menstrual Cups

  • Maintain natural moisture

  • No foreign chemicals or fibers

  • Gentle suction holds cup in place

  • Fewer infections reported in studies

✅ Winner: Menstrual Cups — gentler on the body and better for vaginal health.

🧾 Final Comparison Table

Feature Tampons Menstrual Cups
Material Cotton/rayon Medical-grade silicone/TPE
Wear Time 4–8 hours Up to 12 hours
Cost (per year) ~$120+ ~$25 every 5–10 years
Environmental Impact High waste Low waste / reusable
Beginner Friendly Easy Moderate learning curve
Vaginal Health May cause dryness Maintains natural moisture

💬 Final Thoughts: Which One’s Better?

If you’re looking for a product that’s:

  • Safer for your body

  • Cheaper in the long run

  • Eco-conscious

  • Long-lasting
    Then menstrual cups win hands down.

That said, tampons still work great for many people—especially during travel or as a backup. Some even use both, depending on the situation.

💡 The key is choosing what’s comfortable and healthy for you—but menstrual cups offer some undeniable long-term benefits.

Ready to make the switch?
✨ Shop high-quality, beginner-friendly menstrual cups and eco-care products at NYXCOLLECTION — where sustainability meets comfort.

Back to blog