Are menstrual discs easier than tampons?

Great question — the answer depends on your personal comfort, experience with internal products, and your flow and lifestyle needs. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which might be easier for you:

🩸 Menstrual Discs vs. Tampons: What’s Easier?

✅ Insertion & Learning Curve

  • Tampons:

    • Most people find them easy to insert after a few uses.

    • Applicators make it even easier and more hygienic.

    • Widely used by beginners and available everywhere.

  • Menstrual Discs:

    • Takes a little more practice — they’re wider and need to be tucked behind the pubic bone.

    • No applicator, so you use your fingers.

    • Once learned, many find it just as easy as tampons.

🔹 Verdict: Tampons are easier for beginners, but many users say discs become second nature after a few cycles.

💧 Capacity & Convenience

  • Tampons:

    • Absorb 6–18ml depending on size.

    • Need to be changed every 4–8 hours.

    • Risk of dryness and Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS) if left in too long.

  • Discs:

    • Hold up to 70ml — much more than a tampon.

    • Can be worn for up to 12 hours.

    • Great for overnight use and travel.

🔹 Verdict: Menstrual discs win for heavy flows and fewer bathroom trips.

🌙 Comfort & Movement

  • Tampons:

    • Some feel dryness, especially on light flow days.

    • Can shift or cause discomfort during physical activity.

  • Discs:

    • Sit higher in the vaginal canal, so many people can’t feel them at all.

    • Can be worn during sex (some brands), unlike tampons.

🔹 Verdict: Discs may feel more comfortable and less intrusive — once inserted correctly.

🧼 Messiness & Removal

  • Tampons:

    • Easy and less messy — just pull the string.

    • No reusable option (waste-producing).

  • Discs:

    • Removal can be messier at first, since you scoop with your finger.

    • Reusable discs need to be washed and sterilized.

🔹 Verdict: Tampons are easier and cleaner for removal, but discs can be more sustainable.

🌍 Eco-Friendliness

  • Tampons: Disposable, contribute to landfill waste.

  • Menstrual Discs: Many are reusable, lasting months or even years.

🔹 Verdict: Discs are the more environmentally friendly option.

💡 Final Thoughts: Which Is Easier?

Feature Tampons ✅ Discs ✅
Easy for beginners ✔️
High capacity ✔️
Long wear time ✔️
Comfortable movement ✔️
Easy removal ✔️
Eco-friendly ✔️

🛍️ Want to Try a Disc?

Check out the Reusable Menstrual Disc with Storage Case from Nyx Collection — soft, medical-grade silicone in two sizes for a custom fit.

👩⚕️ Bottom Line:

Tampons are easier to start with, but discs are easier for longer wear, heavy flow, and sustainability. If you’re open to a short learning curve, discs could change your period game.

Back to blog