Are pads healthier than tampons?

A Breakdown of the Pros, Cons, and What’s Best for You

Choosing between pads and tampons is one of the first decisions most people make when they start managing their periods. But when it comes to health, comfort, and safety, is one option better than the other?

Let’s explore the differences, pros and cons, and health considerations so you can make the best choice for your body.

🌸 What Are Pads?

Pads, or sanitary napkins, are absorbent materials worn outside the body and stuck to your underwear. They come in different sizes, thicknesses, and absorbency levels.

✅ Pros of Pads:

  • Non-invasive: No internal insertion needed

  • Lower risk of infection or Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS)

  • Great for overnight use

  • Beginner-friendly

  • Comfortable during lighter flow days

❌ Cons of Pads:

  • May feel bulky

  • Can shift if not placed properly

  • Less discreet under certain clothing

  • Can cause chafing if worn too long

💧 What Are Tampons?

Tampons are small cylinders of absorbent material inserted into the vagina to absorb menstrual blood. They also come in various absorbencies and applicator styles.

✅ Pros of Tampons:

  • More freedom to move (especially for swimming or sports)

  • Invisible under clothes

  • Less external mess

  • Smaller to carry

❌ Cons of Tampons:

  • Risk of TSS (if left in too long — change every 4–8 hours)

  • Can be uncomfortable or painful if inserted incorrectly

  • Some people are sensitive to certain tampon materials

  • Not ideal for very light flow days (can cause dryness)

🩺 Health Considerations

1. Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS)

  • Rare but serious infection linked to tampon use

  • Risk increases if you leave a tampon in too long or use super-absorbent tampons unnecessarily

  • Pads do not carry this risk

2. Vaginal pH & Microbiome

  • Some people find tampons slightly irritating or notice more yeast infections — especially with fragranced varieties

  • Pads are external and less likely to disrupt vaginal balance

3. Materials Matter

  • Whether you use pads or tampons, choose unscented, organic, or chemical-free products when possible

  • Fragrances and bleaching agents can cause irritation or allergies in sensitive users

🤔 So… Are Pads Healthier?

Pads may be the “healthier” option for some people simply because they’re non-invasive and carry zero risk of TSS or internal irritation. However, tampons are not inherently unhealthy — they’re perfectly safe when used properly and changed regularly.

🙋♀️ How to Choose What’s Best for You

Situation Better Option
You're a beginner Pads
You have a very heavy flow Pads or both
You’re going swimming Tampons
You have sensitivity down there Pads or organic
You sleep for long stretches Overnight pads
You’re on the go a lot Tampons

You can also use both — many people use tampons during the day and pads at night.

🌿 Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Whether you choose pads, tampons, menstrual cups, or period underwear, the most important thing is listening to your body and using products safely.

🩸 Menstrual Products Comparison Chart

Feature Pads Tampons Menstrual Cups Period Underwear
Where it's worn Outside the body Inside the vagina Inside the vagina Worn like regular underwear
Absorbency type Absorbs blood externally Absorbs blood internally Collects blood internally Absorbs blood into fabric layers
Reusable? Disposable Disposable ✅ Reusable (up to 10 years) ✅ Reusable (washable)
Beginner-friendly? ✅ Yes Moderate – requires insertion ❌ Takes practice ✅ Yes
Good for heavy flow? ✅ Yes (with overnight/long pads) ✅ Yes (with super absorbency) ✅ Yes ⚠️ Limited for very heavy flow
TSS risk ❌ No ⚠️ Yes (if not changed often) ❌ No ❌ No
Comfort May feel bulky Discreet and body-friendly May feel odd at first Feels like regular underwear
Swimming-friendly? ❌ No ✅ Yes ✅ Yes ❌ No
Eco-friendly? ❌ Disposable = more waste ❌ Disposable = more waste ✅ Reusable, less waste ✅ Reusable, less waste
Cost over time $ – recurring monthly cost $ – recurring monthly cost $$ – one-time purchase, long-term savings $$ – mid-range cost, lasts many cycles
Great for overnight use? ✅ Yes (especially long/thick pads) ⚠️ Only if changed within 8 hrs ✅ Can be worn up to 12 hours ✅ Yes (no leaks with right absorbency)
Ideal for sensitive skin? ✅ Yes (unscented options best) ⚠️ May irritate if fragranced ✅ Hypoallergenic silicone available ✅ Gentle fabrics, no internal use
Learning curve Easy Medium Steep (takes practice & comfort) Easy

🧠 TL;DR — Quick Recommendations

  • New to periods or sensitive skin? Start with pads or period underwear

  • On the go or athletic? Try tampons or a cup

  • Want something eco-friendly and budget-wise long term? Try a menstrual cup or period underwear

  • Need something overnight? Use overnight pads, cups, or period underwear

 

Back to blog