Do reusable menstrual discs work?

Tired of the constant expense of pads and tampons? Intrigued by menstrual cups but find them tricky? Or maybe you're seeking mess-free period intimacy? Enter the reusable menstrual disc – a lesser-known but potentially game-changing option. Let's explore how they work, their lifespan, care, and whether they might be your period soulmate.

What Is a Menstrual Disc? (And How It's Different)

Unlike cups that sit low in the vaginal canal and rely on suction, discs take a different approach:

  1. Shape & Placement: Think shallow, flexible saucer (often made of medical-grade silicone or TPE). It tucks horizontally behind your pubic bone and rests under your cervix, at the widest part of the vaginal fornix.

  2. The "Reservoir": It creates a wide, shallow basin that directly catches menstrual fluid as it exits the cervix.

  3. The Secret Sauce: The Rim: The firm-yet-flexible rim is key. It sits securely tucked behind your pubic bone at the front and wedges into the vaginal fornix at the back. This creates a stable, suction-free seal that holds it in place.

  4. Auto-Dumping (The Game-Changer!): This unique feature sets discs apart. When you bear down (like peeing or having a bowel movement), the pelvic muscles can temporarily dislodge the rim from behind the pubic bone. This allows collected fluid to pass through the disc and out of your body without removing the disc itself. The disc then naturally pops back into place, ready to collect more. This lets you "empty" it partially without removal, often extending wear time to the full 12 hours!

How Does It Actually Work? (Step-by-Step)

  1. Insertion: Fold the disc (common folds: punch-down, C-fold). Relax, insert it angled downward and backward (similar to a tampon without an applicator). Push it all the way back until it feels like it's nestled behind your pubic bone at the front.

  2. Positioning: Once inserted, the rim should spring open. Use a finger to gently nudge the back rim upwards behind your cervix and ensure the front rim is securely tucked behind the pubic bone. You shouldn't feel it when it's correctly placed.

  3. Collection: Blood flows from the cervix directly into the disc's reservoir.

  4. Wear: Wear for up to 12 hours, depending on flow. Experience auto-dumping when using the bathroom? Fantastic! Just wipe as usual.

  5. Removal: Hook your finger under the front rim (behind the pubic bone) and gently pull it down and out. Be prepared – it can be messier than removing a cup due to the shallow basin. Tip: Remove it over the toilet or in the shower.

  6. Empty, Rinse, Reinsert (if continuing wear): Empty contents into the toilet. Rinse thoroughly with cold water first (cold prevents proteins in blood from "setting"), then warm water, or wipe clean with toilet paper/tissue. Reinsert immediately.

The Menstrual Disc Lifespan: How Long Will It Last?

With proper care, a high-quality reusable menstrual disc is designed to last several years, typically 2 to 5 years, sometimes even longer. This is significantly longer than the lifespan of most cups (often 1-5 years) and makes them an incredibly cost-effective and sustainable choice over time.

Factors Affecting Lifespan:

  1. Material Quality: Medical-grade silicone is generally the most durable and inert. TPE is also common but may be slightly less durable over many years.

  2. Care & Cleaning: Following proper cleaning routines (see below!) is paramount. Harsh chemicals, excessive heat, or improper storage can degrade the material.

  3. Physical Damage: Be mindful when handling – avoid sharp fingernails tearing the rim during insertion/removal. Inspect regularly for small tears, thinning, or significant discoloration that might indicate degradation.

  4. Brand & Design: Some brands may use thicker silicone or more robust designs than others.

Keeping Your Disc Clean & Hygienic: A Must-Do Routine

Proper cleaning is essential for preventing infections, odors, and prolonging your disc's life.

During Your Period (Between Uses):

  • After Removal: Always empty the contents into the toilet.

  • Rinse: Rinse thoroughly under cold water first (to rinse away blood without "cooking" it), then under warm water. Use a mild, unscented, oil-free soap if desired (especially at the end of the day). Avoid: Harsh soaps, scented soaps, antibacterial soaps (can disrupt vaginal flora), oil-based cleansers (can degrade silicone).

  • Wipe Option: If rinsing isn't possible (public restroom), thoroughly wipe the disc clean inside and out with unscented toilet paper or a biodegradable wipe designed for menstrual products. Rinse properly at the next opportunity.

  • Reinsert: Reinsert immediately after rinsing/wiping.

At the End of Your Cycle (Sterilization):

  1. Rinse Thoroughly: Wash well with cold then warm water and mild soap.

  2. Boil: Place the disc in a pot of boiling water for 5-10 minutes. Ensure it's fully submerged and not touching the pot's sides/bottom (use a whisk or steamer basket). Crucial Note: Discs with integrated removal strings or loops (like Lumma) should NOT be boiled for extended periods as the string material can degrade. Check your brand's instructions! For these, thorough soap-and-water washing is often sufficient, or steaming may be recommended.

  3. Steam: Use a dedicated menstrual cup/disc steamer for a quick and convenient sanitization cycle (usually 3-10 mins).

  4. Cold Water Sterilizing Solution: Follow the instructions on a product like Milton tablets (used for baby bottles) for a cold soak sanitization method.

  5. Rinse & Dry: After sanitizing, rinse with cool water and let it air dry completely.

  6. Store: Place the completely dry disc in the breathable storage pouch it came with (or a clean cotton bag). Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Avoid airtight containers that can trap moisture.

What About Intimacy?
This is a HUGE perk for many disc users! Because discs sit high in the vaginal fornix, leaving the lower vaginal canal free, mess-free period sex is possible. Many users (and their partners) report not feeling the disc during intercourse. Always check with your partner for comfort.

Pros & Cons: Is a Disc Right for YOU?

Pros:

  • 12-Hour Protection: Longest wear time available.

  • Auto-Dumping: Empty without removal – revolutionary for heavy flow days.

  • Mess-Free Period Sex: A major advantage for many.

  • Suction-Free: Gentler on the cervix, often preferred by those sensitive to cup suction.

  • Great Capacity: Comparable or often higher than large cups.

  • Sustainable & Cost-Effective: Lasts years, minimal waste.

  • Reduced Odor: Blood isn't exposed to air like with pads.

  • Tampon-Like Sensation: When placed correctly, you shouldn't feel it.

Cons:

  • Learning Curve: Insertion and removal can be tricky at first. Removal can be messier.

  • Fit is Crucial: Size matters more than with cups. Finding the right diameter (based on cervix height) is key to preventing leaks or discomfort. Brands often offer multiple sizes.

  • Potential for Mess: Removal, especially during the learning phase, can be messy.

  • Not for Everyone: Anatomy varies; some may find them uncomfortable or difficult to place/remove.

  • Higher Upfront Cost: Though cheaper long-term, initial cost is higher than disposables.

The Verdict:

Reusable menstrual discs are a fantastic, sustainable, and feature-rich option for many menstruators. The 12-hour wear time, auto-dumping capability, and potential for mess-free intimacy are compelling benefits. While they have a learning curve and finding the right fit is essential, the payoff in comfort, convenience, and environmental impact can be immense.

Ready to Try? Research brands (Lumma, Cora, Hello, Ziggy, Nixit, etc.), pay close attention to sizing guides based on cervix height, be patient during the learning phase, and embrace the potential freedom a disc can offer your period! Your body and the planet might thank you

Back to blog