How to Know If Your Menstrual Cup Is the Wrong Size

Signs to Watch For and What to Do Next

Menstrual cups are a fantastic alternative to pads and tampons, but getting the right size is crucial for comfort, leak protection, and overall satisfaction. If your cup isn’t the right size, you might experience discomfort, leaks, or difficulty using it.

Here’s how to tell if your menstrual cup is the wrong size and what you can do about it.

Signs Your Menstrual Cup Might Be the Wrong Size

1. You Experience Frequent Leaks

If your cup leaks regularly despite correct insertion, it might be too small or not creating a proper seal.

2. The Cup Is Uncomfortable or Causes Pain

A cup that’s too large or firm can cause cramping, pressure, or pain during wear. If it pokes or irritates your vaginal walls or cervix, size or firmness could be the issue.

3. Difficulty Inserting or Removing

If the cup is hard to insert or feels stuck when removing, it might be too large or the wrong shape for your anatomy.

4. You Can Feel the Cup or Stem Constantly

A properly sized cup should be comfortable and mostly unnoticeable. If you constantly feel it or it causes irritation, it might be too big or positioned incorrectly.

5. You Empty It Too Frequently or It Overflows Quickly

If the cup fills up very fast or you find yourself emptying it more than expected, the cup might be too small for your flow.

What to Do If Your Cup Is the Wrong Size

  • Try a different size: Smaller if too uncomfortable or leaking; larger if too frequent emptying or difficulty removing.

  • Experiment with firmness: Softer cups are more comfortable but sometimes leak; firmer cups seal better but can be less comfortable.

  • Adjust insertion technique: Sometimes repositioning or rotating the cup helps.

  • Consult brand sizing guides: Brands like DivaCup, Youwei Trade, and Nyx Collection provide detailed sizing advice.

Helpful Video Guide

Watch this clear video to learn more about identifying the right menstrual cup size and troubleshooting fit issues:

How to Tell If Your Menstrual Cup Is The Wrong Size | Menstrual Cup Help

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right menstrual cup size might take a little trial and error, but it’s worth it for the comfort and convenience it brings. Listen to your body and don’t hesitate to try another size or brand if needed.

How to Pick the Perfect Menstrual Cup Size

Based on Your Flow, Age, and Anatomy — Plus Top Brands to Buy From

Choosing the right menstrual cup size is key to a comfortable, leak-free period experience. Let’s break down how your flow, age, and anatomy affect your size choice, and where to find trusted brands.

1. Consider Your Menstrual Flow

Flow Level Recommended Cup Size Notes
Light Flow Small size Smaller capacity, easier to insert
Medium Flow Medium size Balanced capacity and comfort
Heavy Flow Large size Higher capacity, fewer changes

2. Factor in Your Age

Age Group Recommended Size Why?
Under 30 Small or Medium Typically firmer pelvic muscles
Over 30 Medium or Large Pelvic muscles may loosen

3. Know Your Anatomy

  • Childbirth History:

    • No vaginal births → Small or Medium size

    • Vaginal births → Medium or Large size

  • Cervix Height:

    • Low cervix → Shorter cups preferred

    • High cervix → Longer cups work better

  • Pelvic Floor Strength:

    • Strong muscles → Firmer cups recommended

    • Sensitive or relaxed muscles → Softer cups preferred

Putting It Together: Sample Recommendations

Age Flow Childbirth History Cervix Height Suggested Cup Size
25 Light No vaginal births Low Small
28 Medium One vaginal birth Medium Medium
35 Heavy Multiple births High Large
40 Medium No vaginal births Medium Medium

Recommended Menstrual Cup Brands

1. Nyx Collection

  • Sizes: Small, Medium, Large

  • Soft medical-grade silicone, ideal for beginners and various flows

  • Stylish design and eco-friendly materials

  • Available here: NyxCollection.com

2. Youwei Trade

  • Offers multiple sizes and firmness levels

  • Affordable and durable

  • Great for all flow types and anatomy

  • Shop at: Youweitrade.com

3. DivaCup

  • Sizes 1 & 2

  • Trusted classic brand with extensive customer support

  • Available worldwide

4. Lunette

  • Soft and comfortable cups, two sizes

  • High quality and beginner-friendly

Final Tips

  • When in doubt, start with a medium size — it fits many people comfortably.

  • Pay attention to your body’s feedback — discomfort or leaks signal a size or fit issue.

  • Check each brand’s sizing guide carefully before purchasing.

If you provide your age, flow level, childbirth history, and cervix height, I can help pick the ideal menstrual cup size and brand for you!

Back to blog