Is NYX makeup good quality?

Here’s a breakdown of whether NYX makeup is good quality — the positives, the downsides, what people commonly say, and what to look out for.

✅ What People Like About NYX

  1. Great Value for Price
    Many users say NYX delivers good performance for a drugstore brand. Products like matte lipsticks, setting sprays, and lip creams are praised for lasting wear without the high cost. (Influenster)

  2. Wide Shade Range & Inclusivity
    NYX is known for offering a broad variety of shades (foundations, lip colors, concealers) that work for many skin tones. They also have cruelty-free/vegan options. (Which Proxies)

  3. Strong Pigmentation (in many products)
    Eyeliners, lip products, and some lip creams are often highlighted as having strong color payoff. For example, the Soft Matte Lip Cream gets high marks for pigment and wear. (ChickAdvisor)

  4. Good Fan Base & Popularity
    NYX has a strong following among beauty enthusiasts, especially for those who want decent quality on a budget. People often say they can get pro-looking results without luxury prices. (Influenster)

⚠️ Common Complaints & Cons

  1. Inconsistency Across Products
    Some users feel that certain lines are excellent while others are weak. For example, some eyeshadow palettes might be chalky or not pigmented enough. (BeautyOpinions)

  2. Formula Changes / Product Quality Variations
    There are reports of certain classic products being reformulated or manufactured in different locations, leading to perceived drops in quality (e.g., brow pencils that are drier, eyeliners that smudge). (Reddit)

  3. Packaging Issues
    Some complaints about packaging being flimsy, or items arriving damaged. Also, some products break easily or parts fall off. (Trustpilot)

  4. Mismatch of Color & Advertising
    Some customers feel products look different in real life than in photos or online swatches — undertones might be off, or pigments not as described. (Trustpilot)

  5. Customer Service & Shipping Issues
    Several negative reviews relate to shipping delays, damaged or incomplete orders, and difficulty in returns or refunds. (Trustpilot)

🎯 Is NYX Makeup “Good”?

Yes — in many cases. For what you pay, NYX often gives very solid performance. If you’re okay with occasionally having to try different shades, check reviews, and test in person, you can absolutely get quality products.

But if you expect luxury-brand perfection, or if you have very particular standards (e.g. ultra longevity, perfect color match, top-tier packaging), you might find some of NYX’s offerings fall short.

🔍 Tips to Get the Best NYX Experience

  • Try testers or small sizes first to see how product works on your skin.

  • Read recent reviews — formulas sometimes change.

  • Stick to their more universally praised items (lip creams, certain eyeliners, setting sprays) if you want safer bets.

  • Store items properly — fragility seems more of an issue when makeup is handled roughly or transported.

Back to blog