Is silicone or water-based lube better for menopause?

— the best lube for menopause-related vaginal dryness depends on your needs, because silicone and water-based lubricants both have pros and cons. Let’s break it down:

🌸 Menopause & Vaginal Dryness

During menopause, estrogen levels drop, which causes the vaginal tissues to become thinner, drier, and less elastic. This means:

  • Sex can feel painful (dyspareunia).

  • Friction is more irritating than before.

  • A longer-lasting, gentle lube becomes essential.

💧 Water-Based Lubes (Pros & Cons)

✅ Pros:

  • Closest to the body’s natural fluids.

  • Easy to clean, no residue.

  • Condom & toy safe.

  • Many are pH-balanced and glycerin-free, designed for vaginal health (e.g., YES® WB, Sliquid).

⚠️ Cons:

  • Dry out faster → may need reapplying mid-sex.

  • Some contain glycerin/parabens, which can increase risk of thrush/irritation.

👉 Best for: Women who want a natural feel and don’t mind reapplying. Great for everyday intimacy.

🪄 Silicone-Based Lubes (Pros & Cons)

✅ Pros:

  • Super long-lasting (doesn’t dry out).

  • Very slick, reduces friction for thinner menopausal tissue.

  • Waterproof → works in shower/bath.

  • Often hypoallergenic (fewer preservatives).

⚠️ Cons:

  • Harder to wash off (you need soap, not just water).

  • Not safe with silicone sex toys.

  • Can feel “too slippery” for some.

👉 Best for: Women with severe vaginal dryness or painful sex who need maximum glide and comfort.

📝 NHS & Experts Recommend

  • The NHS suggests using vaginal moisturizers (for daily relief, like YES® VM or Replens) plus lubricants (during sex).

  • Both water-based (pH-balanced) and silicone-based are safe — but many gynecologists recommend silicone for women with more severe dryness since it doesn’t dry out.

🌟 Bottom Line

  • Mild dryness → Water-based lube (pH-balanced, glycerin-free).

  • Severe dryness or painful sex → Silicone-based lube for extra glide and protection.

  • Best combo: Use a daily vaginal moisturizer + silicone or water-based lube during sex for the most comfort.

🔍 Menopause Vaginal Dryness Relief: Quick Comparison

Option How It Works Pros Cons Best For
💧 Water-Based Lube Adds temporary moisture during sex; feels like natural fluids - Condom & toy safe - Easy to wash off - Many pH-balanced & glycerin-free options - Dries out faster (may need reapplying) - Some formulas cause irritation (if glycerin/parabens included) Mild to moderate dryness; women who want a natural feel
🪄 Silicone-Based Lube Creates a silky barrier that stays on top of skin (doesn’t absorb/dry out) - Longest-lasting - Great for painful sex - Waterproof (bath/shower sex) - Fewer preservatives = good for sensitive skin - Not safe with silicone toys - Harder to wash off - Can feel “too slippery” for some Moderate to severe dryness; women needing long-lasting comfort
🌿 Vaginal Moisturizer (e.g., YES® VM, Replens) Absorbs into vaginal tissue to restore hydration over time - Daily relief (not just during sex) - Helps tissue stay elastic - Reduces itching & irritation - Not a lube (still need a lubricant for sex) - Must be used regularly (every 2–3 days) Ongoing dryness & irritation outside of sex; best combined with a lube

🌟 Quick Takeaways

  • For everyday comfort: Use a vaginal moisturizer 2–3x per week.

  • For sex:

    • If dryness is mild → a water-based lube is fine.

    • If sex feels painful or tissues are very dry → go with a silicone lube for long-lasting glide.

  • Many women find the best solution is a combo: moisturizer for daily use + lube during intimacy.


Back to blog