The Disadvantages of Period Panties, Pads, Cups & Discs – And Why That’s Okay

When it comes to managing your period, there's no one-size-fits-all solution. Period panties, pads, cups, and discs all have their own pros and cons. We often hear about the benefits — comfort, sustainability, cost-effectiveness — but every product has two sides. Understanding the disadvantages helps you make a more informed and empowered decision.

In this blog, we’ll break down the downsides of each popular period product — and remind you why it’s okay to accept a few flaws if the product mostly works for you.

👙 Disadvantages of Period Panties

Period panties are reusable underwear with built-in absorbent layers, designed to replace or supplement pads or tampons. But they’re not for everyone.

❌ Cons:

  • Drying Time: After washing, they can take 12–24 hours to air dry, which is inconvenient if you don't have multiples.

  • Not for Heavy Flow Alone: Some styles can’t handle very heavy bleeding without leaks.

  • Initial Cost: High-quality brands are more expensive upfront.

  • Odor & Moisture: May feel damp or smelly if worn for too long without changing.

  • Limited Public Changing Options: If you need to change mid-day, you have to carry a used pair — not ideal in public bathrooms.

🩹 Disadvantages of Period Pads

Pads are one of the most widely used period products, especially for beginners. But they come with drawbacks too.

❌ Cons:

  • Bulky Feel: Especially with thick overnight pads, they can feel like diapers.

  • Movement & Chafing: Pads can shift during sports or sleep, causing discomfort or leakage.

  • Not Eco-Friendly: Most disposable pads generate plastic waste.

  • Odor Accumulation: Without frequent changes, pads can smell.

  • Can Feel "Wet": Especially on hot days or with heavy bleeding.

🥄 Disadvantages of Menstrual Cups

Menstrual cups are silicone or rubber devices inserted into the vagina to collect blood. They’re eco-friendly and last years — but not everyone loves them.

❌ Cons:

  • Learning Curve: Inserting and removing the cup takes practice, especially for beginners.

  • Not Always Comfortable: If inserted incorrectly, it can cause pressure or leaks.

  • Public Bathroom Struggles: Cleaning or emptying a cup in a shared bathroom is awkward.

  • Not Ideal for Everyone: People with a low cervix or certain medical conditions may find cups uncomfortable.

  • Risk of Suction Discomfort: Improper removal can feel unpleasant.

🌀 Disadvantages of Menstrual Discs

Discs sit higher up in the vaginal fornix and can be worn during sex — a plus for many. But here’s where they fall short.

❌ Cons:

  • Messy Removal: Blood can spill during removal if you’re not careful.

  • Tricky Placement: Getting the angle and position right takes trial and error.

  • Not Ideal for Heavy Days Alone: May need to be changed more frequently.

  • Can Slip: If not placed correctly, it can dislodge.

  • Can Be Expensive: Disposable discs cost more over time, and reusable ones may not suit everyone.

🤝 Everything Has Two Sides

Whether it’s a cup, pad, disc, or panty — every product has advantages and disadvantages.

✅ Advantages may include:

  • Eco-friendliness

  • Long-term savings

  • Comfort

  • Discreet use

❌ Disadvantages might involve:

  • Learning curves

  • Cleaning hassle

  • Leakage risks

  • Public restroom inconvenience

💬 That’s Life: No Perfect Product

When you buy something, you're not just buying a benefit — you're choosing to accept its downsides too. A product may improve over time, but even the best innovations have limitations.

So ask yourself:

“Can I accept the disadvantages of this product?”

If yes — great, you’ve found your match.
If not — it’s okay to try something else.

🌸 Final Thoughts

The best period product is the one that fits your body, lifestyle, and comfort level — not what others say is "best." Don’t chase perfection. Instead, look for what works for you most of the time, and be flexible enough to change when needed.

If period panties feel too wet, try a cup.
If pads are bulky, try a disc.
If the cup is too much, start with a pad.
It’s your period. You’re in control.

Want to explore more period products that match your needs?
Check out our curated collection at NYXCOLLECTION — where comfort meets practicality.

Because buying better doesn’t mean buying perfect. It means buying what works for you.

Back to blog