What Are the Disadvantages of Using a Menstrual Cup? A Balanced Look

Menstrual cups have become increasingly popular as a sustainable, cost-effective alternative to disposable period products. Made from medical-grade silicone or rubber, these flexible cups collect menstrual blood internally and can be reused for years.

While menstrual cups offer many benefits — like reducing waste and saving money — they’re not perfect for everyone. In this blog, we’ll explore some of the common disadvantages and challenges users might face with menstrual cups, so you can decide if they’re right for you.

1. Learning Curve and Initial Discomfort

Using a menstrual cup requires some practice to get used to:

  • Insertion and removal can be tricky at first. It might take a few cycles to feel comfortable inserting the cup properly without leaks or discomfort.

  • Some users experience mild discomfort or pressure when the cup isn’t inserted correctly.

  • Different folding techniques exist, and finding the right one for your body can take time.

2. Maintenance and Cleaning

Unlike disposable products, menstrual cups must be cleaned thoroughly to maintain hygiene:

  • You need access to clean water for rinsing and washing.

  • Sterilizing the cup between cycles (boiling for 5–10 minutes) requires extra effort.

  • In public restrooms, it can be inconvenient or embarrassing to empty and clean the cup discreetly.

3. Not Suitable for Everyone

Certain medical or personal conditions may make menstrual cups unsuitable:

  • Women with very heavy flow may find they need to empty the cup frequently.

  • Those with sensitive vaginas or allergies to silicone or rubber should avoid menstrual cups.

  • Women who are uncomfortable with internal products or have difficulty with insertion may prefer external options like pads or underwear.

4. Risk of Leaks and Mess

Although menstrual cups are designed to form a seal, leaks can happen:

  • Incorrect insertion or an ill-fitting cup can cause leakage.

  • During heavy flow days, you may need to empty the cup more often than expected.

  • Leaks might lead to staining clothes or bedding, which can be stressful.

5. Size and Fit Issues

Finding the right cup size is crucial but can be confusing:

  • There are usually multiple sizes based on age, childbirth history, and cervix height.

  • An ill-fitting cup can cause discomfort or leaks.

  • Some brands don’t offer enough size options, limiting choices for different anatomies.

6. Social and Cultural Barriers

  • Some people feel uneasy or embarrassed about touching their genital area.

  • In certain cultures, using internal menstrual products might be taboo.

  • Menstrual cups require a level of comfort with one’s body that not everyone has.

Conclusion: Are Menstrual Cups Right for You?

Menstrual cups are an eco-friendly and economical period product, but they come with challenges like the learning curve, cleaning requirements, and potential fit issues. They are best suited for those willing to experiment and adapt, who appreciate sustainability, and who are comfortable with internal menstrual care.

If you’re curious, consider trying a starter set from trusted brands like:

  • Nyx Collection Menstrual Cups

  • DivaCup

  • Saalt Cup

Remember: no period product is one-size-fits-all. Your comfort, convenience, and health should always come first.

Back to blog