What are the pros and cons of silicone and water based lube?

Here’s a clear breakdown of the pros and cons of silicone vs. water-based lubricants so you can see which one fits your needs best:

πŸ’§ Water-Based Lubricants

βœ… Pros:

  • Safe with all condoms & toys (latex, polyisoprene, polyurethane, silicone toys, etc.).

  • Easy to clean β†’ rinses off with water, no residue.

  • Lightweight & natural feel (closest to body’s natural fluids).

  • Widely available β†’ most common type of lube.

  • Some are pH-balanced & glycerin-free β†’ great for sensitive skin and UTI-prone people.

⚠️ Cons:

  • Dries out faster β†’ may need reapplication during longer sessions.

  • Can get sticky if it evaporates.

  • Cheaper brands may contain glycerin or parabens β†’ can increase yeast/UTI risk.

  • Not ideal in water (shower, bath, pool) since it washes away.

✨ Silicone-Based Lubricants

βœ… Pros:

  • Super long-lasting β†’ no need for constant reapplication.

  • Waterproof β†’ perfect for shower or pool fun.

  • Silky smooth texture β†’ stays slick, great for people with dryness.

  • Less likely to cause yeast/UTIs (since bacteria can’t feed on silicone).

  • Good for anal sex β†’ more cushion and glide.

⚠️ Cons:

  • Not safe with silicone toys β†’ can break down the surface, making them sticky/porous.

  • Harder to clean off β†’ needs soap to remove completely.

  • Can stain sheets/clothes if spilled.

  • More expensive than water-based lubes.

πŸ”Ž Quick Comparison Chart

Feature Water-Based πŸ’§ Silicone-Based ✨
Condom Safe Yes βœ… Yes βœ… (except polyisoprene sometimes)
Toy Safe Yes βœ… ❌ Not with silicone toys
Longevity Shorter ⏳ Very long-lasting ⏳✨
Cleanup Easy, washes with water Needs soap, can linger
Shower Use ❌ Washes away βœ… Stays slick in water
Texture Light, natural feel Thick, silky-smooth
Cost Usually cheaper πŸ’² More expensive πŸ’²πŸ’²
Best For Vaginal sex, toys, everyday use Anal sex, shower play, dryness issues

πŸ‘‰ Bottom line:

  • Go water-based if you want something light, easy to clean, and toy-friendly.

  • Go silicone-based if you want long-lasting glide, are prone to dryness, or plan to use lube in water.


Back to blog