Why are menstrual discs so messy?

Here’s the honest truth — menstrual discs can be messy, but it usually depends on how they’re inserted, removed, and your comfort level with your body.

🩸 1. Why Menstrual Discs Feel Messier Than Tampons or Cups

🔄 Position & Removal Technique

  • Discs sit horizontally at the base of the cervix, unlike cups (which sit vertically in the vaginal canal).

  • When you remove them, there’s no suction — so blood can spill easily if you’re not careful.

  • Removal often requires reaching in deeper and tilting the disc correctly to avoid leaks.

🖐️ Finger Contact

  • You often have to use a finger to hook or pinch the edge of the disc to pull it out.

  • This direct contact with menstrual fluid can feel messier if you're not used to it.

🛁 “Auto-Dumping” During Toilet Use

  • Discs are designed to self-empty slightly when you bear down (like during pooping or peeing). This can feel unexpected or messy if you're unaware of it.

💡 2. Tips to Make Menstrual Discs Less Messy

  • Remove in the shower (especially your first few times).

  • Tilt and pinch the disc at a slight angle while removing to reduce spills.

  • Practice during light flow days to get confident with the process.

  • Keep wipes or tissues nearby for cleanup if needed.

✅ 3. Why Some Still Prefer Discs (Despite the Mess)

  • Long wear time – up to 12 hours

  • Can be worn during sex

  • Holds more fluid than tampons or pads

  • More eco-friendly (especially reusable discs)

🛍️ Recommended Option:

Try a disc with a firm rim and finger notch for easier removal:
👉 2pcs Reusable Menstrual Disc – Nyx Collection

Final Thoughts

Yes, menstrual discs can be messier at first — but with practice, many users say they actually feel cleaner, freer, and less wasteful in the long run. It's all about getting used to the learning curve!

Back to blog