Are menstrual discs healthy?

Yes, high-quality menstrual discs are generally considered a healthy option for most users—when used correctly. Here's a detailed, evidence-based breakdown:

✅ Why Menstrual Discs Are Healthy

  1. Medical-Grade Materials

    • Made of hypoallergenic, non-toxic silicone or TPE (thermoplastic elastomer).

    • No chemicals, dyes, or absorbent fibers (unlike tampons/pads).

    • Biocompatible and non-porous → Prevents bacterial growth.

  2. Lower Infection Risk

    • Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS) risk is extremely low (lower than tampons):

      • Discs collect rather than absorb fluid → No vaginal dryness or micro-tears.

      • No superabsorbent materials to trap bacteria.

    • Reduced yeast/BV risk: Silicone/TPE doesn’t disrupt vaginal pH.

  3. No Irritation or Allergies

    • Safe for sensitive skin → No rashes, itching, or contact dermatitis (common with scented pads/tampons).

  4. Supports Vaginal Health

    • Doesn’t dry out vaginal mucosa → Preserves natural lubrication.

    • Less odor (blood isn’t exposed to air like with pads).

⚠️ Potential Risks (and How to Avoid Them)

  1. Improper Hygiene

    • Risk: Bacterial buildup if not cleaned properly → Infections.

    • Fix:

      • Rinse with cold water after removal.

      • Sterilize (boil/steam) between cycles.

      • Use mild, fragrance-free soap.

  2. IUD Displacement

    • Risk: Rare, but disc rim could catch IUD strings during removal.

    • Fix:

      • Break the disc’s seal gently before pulling out.

      • Consult your OB-GYN (most say discs are safe with IUDs).

  3. Anatomical Fit Issues

    • Risk: A too-large disc may cause cramping; too-small may leak.

    • Fix: Measure cervix height → Choose the right size (e.g., Lumma S/M/L).

🔬 Science-Backed Benefits

  • 12-hour wear: Reduces insertion/removal frequency → Less bacterial introduction.

  • Auto-dumping: Empty without removal on heavy days → Lowers overflow risk.

  • Eco-friendly: Reusable discs reduce landfill waste by 99% vs. disposables.

(Source: NIH Study on Menstrual Products)

🩺 OB-GYN Recommendations

"Discs are a safe, healthy alternative for most. Just avoid cheap, non-medical-grade materials and sterilize monthly."
– Dr. Jen Gunter, The Vagina Bible author

"I recommend discs to patients with recurrent infections—they’re gentler than tampons."
– Dr. Alyssa Dweck, OB-GYN

❓ Discs vs. Other Products: Health Comparison

Product TSS Risk Chemical Exposure Vaginal Irritation
Menstrual Disc Very Low None Rare
Tampon Moderate Bleaching agents, dyes Common (drying effect)
Pad None Fragrances, plastics Skin rashes, sweating
Cup Very Low None Possible (suction)

🚫 When Discs Are NOT Healthy

Avoid discs if you have:

  • Pelvic organ prolapse (disc may worsen pressure).

  • Untreated vaginal infection (wait until cleared).

  • Latex allergy (some disposables contain latex; reusables do not).

✅ Best Practices for Healthy Use

  1. Hand hygiene: Wash hands before insertion/removal.

  2. Sterilize monthly: Boil 5-10 mins or use a steam bag.

  3. Replace every 2-5 years: Discs degrade over time.

  4. Listen to your body: Remove if you feel pain, pressure, or unusual odor.

💡 The Verdict

Menstrual discs are a healthy, low-risk option for most menstruators—if you:

  • Choose medical-grade reusable discs (e.g., Cora, Saalt, Lumma).

  • Prioritize hygiene (sterilize between cycles!).

  • Get the right fit (size matters!).

For maximum safety: Avoid disposable discs (like Flex) long-term—they contain plastics and can’t be sterilized.

🌸 **Healthy periods start with informed choices. When in doubt, consult your gynecologist!

Вернуться к блогу