Are pads or tampons worse for the environment?

When it comes to environmental impact, both pads and tampons generate a lot of waste—but pads are generally worse due to their plastic content and decomposition time. Let’s break it down.

🧻 Pads vs. Tampons: Environmental Impact Comparison

Feature Tampons Pads
Primary Materials Cotton, rayon, plastic applicator (optional) Cotton, rayon, plus large amounts of plastic
Plastic Content Applicator + wrapper (if any) Wrapper, backing, adhesive strip, absorbent core
Decomposition Time 500+ years (with plastic applicators) Up to 800 years due to more plastic
Waste per Cycle 20–25 pieces 20–30 pieces
Flushable? No (can clog pipes and pollute water) No (must be wrapped and binned)
Recyclable? No No

🌍 Why Pads Are Worse for the Environment

❌ 1. More Plastic

  • A typical pad is made of up to 90% plastic.

  • That includes the leak-proof layer, the core absorbent layer, and even the top sheet.

❌ 2. Longer to Decompose

  • Pads can take 500–800 years to fully break down in landfills.

  • Even biodegradable ones may not decompose without industrial composting.

🌬️ Tampons: Slightly Better, But Not Ideal

✔️ 1. Less Plastic (Sometimes)

  • Organic tampons with no applicator or a cardboard applicator are a more eco-conscious choice.

  • Still produce waste each month, and many users flush them—causing sewage pollution.

❌ 2. Applicators and Wrappers Still Add Up

  • Plastic tampon applicators don’t decompose and are found on beaches worldwide.

  • Even compostable ones need specific facilities to break down safely.

♻️ Greener Alternatives to Both

If you're concerned about the planet, here are better options:

Product Waste Level Lifespan Eco Rating
Menstrual Cup Very low 5–10 years ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Reusable Disc Very low 1–5 years ⭐⭐⭐⭐½
Cloth Pads Low 3–5 years ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Period Underwear Medium 2–4 years ⭐⭐⭐½
Organic Tampons (no applicator) Medium Disposable ⭐⭐

💬 Final Verdict: Which Is Worse?

✅ Pads are worse for the environment due to:

  • Higher plastic content

  • Slower decomposition

  • More landfill impact

❗ Tampons (especially organic, applicator-free ones) are slightly better, but still single-use and wasteful long-term.

✅ Pads are worse because they contain more plastic, take longer to decompose (up to 800 years), and generate more landfill waste.

❗ Tampons—especially organic, applicator-free ones—are a bit better but still produce single-use waste and potential pollution.

🌿 Where to Shop Eco-Friendly Menstrual Products (No Youwei Trade — Use Nyx Collection Instead!)

Вернуться к блогу