Is a cup or disc better for heavy periods?

Spoiler: Discs often win, but it’s not a knockout. Here’s your ultimate guide to choosing wisely.

⚔️ Round 1: Capacity & Leak Defense

Metric Menstrual Cup Menstrual Disc
Volume Holds 20-40ml (super cup: ~40ml) Holds 50-70ml (2x most cups!)
Leak Triggers Sudden gushes can break suction seal Horizontal design contains "floods" better
Active Wear May leak during inversions (yoga, sleep) Stays sealed during exercise/sleep
Auto-Dumping No (must remove to empty) Yes! Bear down to empty without removal (game-changer for heavy days!)

👉 Winner: Disc
Why? Higher capacity + auto-dumping = fewer emergency bathroom trips.

⛑️ Round 2: Comfort & Convenience

Cup Disc
❌ Suction can worsen cramps for some ✅ No suction—sits loosely behind pubic bone
❌ Stem may irritate low cervix ✅ No stem—fits all cervix heights
❌ Must remove to empty (messy) ✅ Auto-dump mid-day = no removal needed
❌ 8-hour max wear ✅ 12-hour wear (even on heavy days!)

👉 Winner: Disc
Why? Auto-dumping + 12-hour wear = unmatched convenience.

🩸 Round 3: Real Heavy Flow Scenarios

Scenario 1: Overnight Flooding

  • Cup: Risk of overflow if >40ml; suction may fail lying down.

  • Disc: 70ml capacity + gravity-resistant seal = dry mornings.

Scenario 2: Work/Meeting Marathon

  • Cup: May require mid-day removal (messy in public).

  • Disc: Auto-dump in toilet without removing disc. Wipe + go!

Scenario 3: Intense Cramps + Heavy Flow

  • Cup: Suction can amplify cramps.

  • Disc: No suction + medical-grade silicone = less pain.

⚠️ When a Cup Might Still Win

Consider a cup if:

  • You have a very high cervix (discs can be harder to reach).

  • You prefer suction security over auto-dumping.

  • You’re on a budget (cups start at $15; discs $25-$40).
    → Top Heavy-Flow Cups: Merula XL (50ml), Super Jennie (42ml), Venus Large (47ml).

🏆 The Heavy Flow Champion: Discs

For 80% of heavy bleeders, discs deliver:
✅ Higher capacity (no 3 a.m. panic changes).
✅ Auto-dumping (avoid public removal disasters).
✅ 12-hour protection (double a cup’s safe wear time).
✅ Cramp-friendly design (no suction tugging).

🔍 Choosing YOUR Heavy-Flow Hero

Try a disc if:

  • You flood tampons/cups in 2 hours.

  • You want overnight leak protection.

  • Cramps make insertion/removal exhausting.
    → Top Heavy-Flow Discs:

  • Lumma Unique High Capacity (70ml + removal string)

  • Nixit (soft rim, 70ml, great for cramps)

  • Cora (firmer rim, 60ml, secure for activity)

Stick with a cup if:

  • Auto-dumping feels messy/unpredictable.

  • You have a very high cervix or shallow pubic bone.

💡 Pro Tips for Heavy Flow Disc Users

  1. Size up if leaking: Try 65-70mm discs (Lumma Large, Ziggy 2).

  2. Auto-dump smartly: Do it before the disc is full (every 3-4 hrs on surge days).

  3. Pair with backup: Wear period underwear overnight for peace of mind.

The Verdict

While cups are powerful allies, menstrual discs are the heavy-flow MVP for their massive capacity, auto-dumping superpower, and marathon 12-hour wear. The learning curve pays off in saved sleep, sanity, and stained sheets. Give discs 2 cycles to master—you might just retire your cup for good. 🩸💪

Still unsure? Grab a $10 box of Flex Disposable Discs to test-drive the experience!

Вернуться к блогу