Is a disk better than a cup?

The answer depends entirely on your anatomy, priorities, and lifestyle. Neither discs nor cups are universally "better"—but one might be better for you. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide:

🔄 Key Differences at a Glance

Feature Menstrual Disc Menstrual Cup
Placement Tucks behind pubic bone, sits below cervix Sits low in vaginal canal, uses suction
Insertion Often easier (shallow) Steeper learning curve
Removal Can be messy; "hook-and-pull" method Requires breaking suction
Sensation Usually unfelt (when placed correctly) May cause pressure if low/firm
Auto-Dumping ✅ Yes (empty without removal) ❌ No
Period Sex ✅ Mess-free possible ❌ Not possible
IUD Safety 🟡 Low risk (rim grip caution) 🟡 Low risk (suction caution)
Capacity ⬆️ Higher (60-80ml) ⬇️ Lower (20-40ml)
12-Hour Wear ✅ Yes ✅ Yes

🏆 When a Disc Might Be BETTER For You:

  1. You want mess-free period sex
    → Discs sit high, leaving the vaginal canal free.

  2. You have a heavy flow or long days
    → Auto-dumping lets you "reset" without removal.

  3. Suction feels uncomfortable
    → Discs rely on anatomy, not suction.

  4. You have a high cervix
    → Discs accommodate higher placements.

  5. You struggle with cup removal
    → Discs have no suction to break.

Popular Discs: Cora, Saalt Disc, Hello Disc, Lumma.

🥇 When a Cup Might Be BETTER For You:

  1. You hate messy removal
    → Cup removal is cleaner (blood stays contained).

  2. You have a low cervix or pelvic organ prolapse
    → Shorter cups fit better (e.g., MeLuna Shorty).

  3. You prefer a stem for easy grip
    → Most cups have stems/rings for removal.

  4. You’re budget-conscious
    → More affordable cup options exist (e.g., June Cup).

  5. You want minimal re-adjustment
    → Cups rarely auto-dump unexpectedly.

Popular Cups: Saalt Soft, Lena Cup, Organicup, DivaCup.

⚠️ Shared Downsides of Both:

  • Learning curve (1-3 cycles to master).

  • Sterilization required (boil monthly).

  • Fit is critical (wrong size = leaks/pain).

  • Not ideal during infections (yeast/BV).

🩺 Health & Safety Notes

  • TSS Risk: Extremely low for both, but slightly lower for discs (less vaginal contact).

  • Materials: Both use medical-grade silicone (safe).

  • Hygiene: Identical protocols—rinse during period, sterilize after.

💬 Real User Experiences

*“Switched to a disc after 5 years with cups. Auto-dumping changed my life on heavy days!”* — Lena, 29
“Cups were too long for my low cervix. Discs pressed on my bladder. Now I use period underwear.” — Riya, 32

✅ How to Test Which is Right For You

  1. Assess your cervix height (during your period!).

  2. Prioritize your top need:

    • Sex? → Disc

    • Easy removal? → Cup

    • Heavy flow? → Disc

    • Low cervix? → Short cup

  3. Try budget-friendly options first:

The Verdict

Choose a DISC if you:

  • Prioritize period sex or auto-dumping.

  • Have a high cervix or dislike suction.
    Choose a CUP if you:

  • Prefer cleaner removal and stems.

  • Have a low cervix or want more size options.

Still unsure? Try a disposable Flex Disc first ($12 for 8 discs)—no commitment!

💡 Pro Tip: Many people own both and alternate based on their cycle (e.g., disc for heavy days, cup for lighter days).

Вернуться к блогу